TreasureNet
TreasureNet - The Original Treasure Hunting Website! TreasureNet - The Original Treasure Hunting Website! White's Metal Detectors - See What's In The Ground Before You Dig! Western & Eastern Treasures Magazine! J.W. Fisher's Underwater Search Equipment Kellyco Metal Detectors! Sedwick Treasure Auctions New England Detectors Big Boys Hobbies
White's Electronics
Minelab
New York State belt buckle Spanish Cob CONNECTICUT ONE PIECE MILITARY BUTTON Gold Signet Ring Civil War Camp Finds Celtic Gold Quarter Stater Maryland Militia Officer Button 1793 Flowing Hair Wreath and Bars Large Cent 2 and a half ounce nugget French Treasures 2011

Is this authentic?

« previous next »
4638 views | Pages: [1]   Down
  Bookmark This! | Print  
*
United StatesOffline
Posts: 2

Posted Jan 12, 2010, 09:19:33 am

Hi everyone, first post in a new forum so be gentle Smiley

I'm working with an eBay consignment store, looking to sell a few knick-knacks for a kindly old gent whose grandfather was heavily into collecting old coins, stamps & other curiosities.  One of the things that's in his stash is a small pewter button with the letters "USA" sort of linked to each other like a chain. Just from looking a bit online it seems that this was a common Revolutionary War button design, but the button is in such great condition compared to the examples I've seen that I'm skeptical of calling it authentic.  Here are some pictures:




Does this look like a replica, or could it be authentic?  I'd appreciate any help with this.

Thanks,
KF

*
Offline
Posts: 1436

Reply To This Topic #1 Posted Jan 12, 2010, 02:45:43 pm

not sure if authentic or not but is definantly a representation of a continental army uniform button...this fellow should be of help..

http://www.troianicollector.com/
*
United StatesOffline
Posts: 2756
Northern VA vayank54 vayank54

Detector used Detector(s) Used - Whites Blue Gray & Tesoro Cibola

Reply To This Topic #2 Posted Jan 12, 2010, 08:42:02 pm

It sure looks good.  You might also ask William Leigh at civilwarbuttons.com
*
United StatesOffline
Posts: 2

Reply To This Topic #3 Posted Jan 13, 2010, 06:21:45 am

Thanks, I'll try both suggestions.   

The seller has no idea about the origins of the button, he just found this along with some other miscellany among his grandfather's things and brought it to us as an alternative to throwing it away (Which is a good thing, because we've already found some valuable stuff in there.)  We've already found some historical items that I could verify as authentic, so it wouldn't be out of the realm of possibility for this to be as well.

*
United StatesOffline
Posts: 2384
Pittsfield Ma.
Detector used Detector(s) Used - Whites Prism IV

_____________
Bannered!
1783 King George III "GEORGIVS" backwards "S" - Revolutionary War, British Cartridge Sling Belt Tip - 1786 "VERMONTENSIUM" Copper Ryder 7 var.
_____________


Primary Interest: All Types Of Treasure Hunting

Reply To This Topic #4 Posted Jan 15, 2010, 04:55:56 am

Vague, "I don't know", responses are a clue about the seller and his goods. "My grandfathers collection", "My husbands death or divorce", Most of these people know what they have, and what it is worth.      "Caveat Emptor"               Hogge

1783 CFT. KG III 1/2 Penny (25-83A)-1 of 3 known *Sold $3,750, Vermont Landscape Coppers Ryder 6 *Sold $760, Ryder7 (Avatar)** Sold $1,275*, Royal Irish Artillery Cartridge Box Sling Belt Tip,(3)- GW Inaugural Buttons-2-Cobb# 17-J.* Sold both--$405 and $400. *GW Button Cobb 17-I
*
Offline
Posts: 11075
Dirtyville
Detector used Detector(s) Used - Explorer

_____________
Bannered!
1699 Spanish Cob - Revolutionary War Officer's Button & Colonial Silver
_____________

Reply To This Topic #5 Posted Jan 19, 2010, 01:16:23 pm




   If that's a reproduction I'm fooled!

I'm as dirty as I look!
*
Offline
Posts: 11075
Dirtyville
Detector used Detector(s) Used - Explorer

_____________
Bannered!
1699 Spanish Cob - Revolutionary War Officer's Button & Colonial Silver
_____________

Reply To This Topic #6 Posted Jan 19, 2010, 01:19:11 pm

not sure if authentic or not but is definantly a representation of a continental army uniform button...this fellow should be of help..

http://www.troianicollector.com/

 
  Short cut.

  http://forum.treasurenet.com/index.php/topic,285830.0.html

I'm as dirty as I look!
*
United StatesOffline
Posts: 2384
Pittsfield Ma.
Detector used Detector(s) Used - Whites Prism IV

_____________
Bannered!
1783 King George III "GEORGIVS" backwards "S" - Revolutionary War, British Cartridge Sling Belt Tip - 1786 "VERMONTENSIUM" Copper Ryder 7 var.
_____________


Primary Interest: All Types Of Treasure Hunting

Reply To This Topic #7 Posted Jan 20, 2010, 01:05:05 pm

After looking at images of your button and other authentic USA buttons, side by side, I would have to say the one you have IS authentic. Everything really matches up well. JMO. This is a well kept relic. Obviously not a ground found piece. The best I've ever seen!                   I'm not an expert. The Troiani site would be the place to go. Send him an E-mail.              Hogge

1783 CFT. KG III 1/2 Penny (25-83A)-1 of 3 known *Sold $3,750, Vermont Landscape Coppers Ryder 6 *Sold $760, Ryder7 (Avatar)** Sold $1,275*, Royal Irish Artillery Cartridge Box Sling Belt Tip,(3)- GW Inaugural Buttons-2-Cobb# 17-J.* Sold both--$405 and $400. *GW Button Cobb 17-I
*
United StatesOffline
Posts: 42
Tioga County, Pa

Reply To This Topic #8 Posted Nov 05, 2010, 06:35:44 pm

WOW, That's a super find, Good One icon_thumright
Tags: Revolutionary War  Button  usa  pewter 
Pages: [1]   Go Up
  Bookmark This! | Print  
 

RECENTLY FEATURED W&ET ARTICLES...
feature article feature article feature article feature article feature article feature article feature article





Copyright 1994-2012 TreasureNet (tm) All Rights Reserved.
Powered by SMF 1.1.16 | SMF © 2006-2011, Simple Machines LLC
SimplePortal 2.3.3 © 2008-2010, SimplePortal


If you've found this site entertaining or informative,
toss some appreciation in the tip jar.
TreasureNet Tip Jar
Treasure Hunting By State Treasure Hunting By Country Treasure Auctions






TERMS OF USE

TOP


Google visited this page Feb 06, 2012, 12:33:39 am