Max,
The smaller one is my favorite too, for most but not all situations. I am out here doing lakes and rivers on Washington. I just got another new scoop from a new maker this past week. It is great in the rocks! 5.5 inches wide, 5 inches tall and 8 inches long! It is the best in the rocks!
Kind regards,
Steve
i went with the smaller of the two with the small square holes
works great in the water and damp zone and it was lighter
the bigger model was just toooo heavy for damp and shallow, but god did it ever work good in the waist to chest deep zone.
eliminated the floating sifter for me.......when we worked on the bay, but i will say some of my upcoming roadtrips will require a floating sifter and this scoop.
chucks scoop is a great scoop also, but i found it to be a might heavy, but has a great foot pad assembly.
i think don dodson with northgeorgia relics is or will be carrying the SnS scoops also.
max