Bullets - looking for info on 3

My guess is that these aren't that old but I was wondering if anyone could help me with the time era?  I found a whole mess of them in the same general area and I am trying to get an idea of what might have been going on there -



Thanks!

.44 percussion pistol, .45 ACP 230 gr. hardball, .45 ACP 200 gr. SWC (semi wad cutter)

 blackpowder cap and ball type 44 cal bullet (most likely shot from a "modern made" replica gun)--  45 APC  full metal jacket modern copper jacket pistol round -- 45 cal soft lead type semi wad cutter round also modern --I'd say target practice was going on  most likely from the looks of it .

That's what I said.

I was just agreeing with you as far as the id goes --as well as pointing out that the black powder round was modern most likely * --since it can be  either old or new ( old lead tends to oxide --making it whitish colored) and since he was trying to figger out what occured there ---I explained that the "old" cap and ball type  bullets --might not be so old * (fired from a replica gun most likely) -- and that someone was most likely target shooting.

appreciate it...Just being tacky. I figured that it was the lag between "ask" and "reply"
Also I tend to be blunt with the answer when ask a question. Wife says rude.

I think the mix of old looking (cap and ball) and modern looking bullets might have made him go hummm? -- sometime folks do not think about the fact that "modern " repilca cap and ball guns shoot the same bullets as the real old "cap and ball" guns of long ago -- thankfully lead tends to oxide over time in most soils turning whitish --so it normally its not that hard to tell the newer ones from the old ones  --- I tend to try to fill in the "full answer" -- talkative sort that I am.

Thanks Guys!

Thanks for the help!

So the first one might be older... I did find that one a bit away from the others and I did find only the one so it might possibly be earlier.  A little more likely than if I found it in the pile I found of the others I suppose.

Thanks for the help!

So the first one might be older... I did find that one a bit away from the others and I did find only the one so it might possibly be earlier.  A little more likely than if I found it in the pile I found of the others I suppose.



I would say "yes",aside from the above mentioned possibility of it being fired from a replica type weapon.

Not to be rude but the third bullet is not a 200gr. 45 acp.  The 200 grainer is much shorter. I have reloaded hundreds of cast lead 200 grain .45 ACP semi-wadcutter rounds for competition shooting.   If #2 is a 230 grainer then #3 would be heavier as it looks to be longer and pure lead.  My guess, assuming it is a .45 caliber would be a 250 gr. semi-wadcutter from a .45 Colt revolver.  Not to be rude however. Wait , I said that already.   M nty